Transparency & Verification Score
What the score measures, how items are graded, and what it does not tell you.
Published 2026-09-30 · Updated 2026-10-20
English is the authoritative version. Translations are provided for convenience.
Key points
- The score measures how transparent and verifiable a product's public information is. It is not a credit rating.
- Each of 30 items is graded by what could be verified and against which source.
- Structural risks are listed as separate risk notes and do not change the score.
High transparency is not a recommendation. The score is not investment advice; readers should form their own judgement.
What the score measures
The Transparency & Verification Score (TVS) measures two things about a tokenized product's public information: whether it is disclosed, and whether RWA.NGO could verify it. A statement that is disclosed but cannot be checked, or that does not match the evidence, is a verification problem of a different degree, and the score treats it that way.
The score does not measure credit quality, returns or whether a product is suitable for anyone. Risks that come from how a product is built are set out separately as risk notes.
Which products are scored
Every active listed product is scored. Products that only record interests and cannot be bought by investors are described but not scored. Products that had ended before the score was introduced are not scored; a product that ends later keeps its last score.
A product is listed and scored only when public primary documents identify three things: the legal vehicle, the issuing entity and the on-chain token. Products that do not meet this threshold, or that must be counted apart, are recorded in a separate list with the reason: tokens held only on a permissioned ledger; registry records with no investor-held token; tokens that hold another tokenized product (counted apart to avoid double counting); a public token whose legal vehicle or issuer could not be identified; announced but not yet live; ended or winding down. Separately listed products are not scored, and their issuer-stated sizes are counted apart from the main totals. The same evidence standard applies to both lists.
Each product is scored on its own, including several products from the same issuer.
What is graded
Thirty items are grouped in five dimensions:
- Issuer and legal structure: the issuing entity, domicile and governing law, regulatory status, public access to offering documents, what the token legally represents, asset segregation, and investor eligibility.
- Assets and custody: underlying assets and holdings, custodian, auditor and audited financial statements, independent checks of reserves or holdings, related-party custody and transactions, and the investment manager or sponsor.
- Valuation, size and reporting: the NAV or price method, the stated size, whether that size matches on-chain data, fees, periodic reports, and the administrator, valuation agent or trustee.
- Subscription, redemption and transfer: subscription and redemption terms, suspensions and gates, transfer restrictions, and the transfer agent or registrar.
- Token and on-chain: the official contract address, source verification on an explorer, disclosure of admin powers, smart-contract audits, how the on-chain record relates to the legal register, and bridging or wrapping. These items are graded chain by chain.
Some items do not apply to some structures, for example a fund administrator for a physical gold token. Items that do not apply are left out of the score.
How each item is graded
Each item is placed in one of these grades:
| Grade | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Verified against an independent source | Matches a regulator filing or register, audited statements, an independent assurance report or data read directly from the blockchain; or the issuer's document was approved by a regulator or similar authority |
| Verified against the issuer's own documents only | The issuer's documents agree with each other, but nothing independent confirms them |
| Disclosed but not verifiable | Only secondary sources, a statement with no document behind it, or material shown only to investors |
| Not disclosed | The issuer's main documents were checked and do not state it |
| Inconsistent | The disclosure conflicts with a regulator filing, audited statements or on-chain data, or the issuer's own documents contradict each other with nothing saying which applies |
| Not yet assessed | Not yet graded; earns nothing until it is |
"Not disclosed" and "Inconsistent" sit in the lowest tier together. Both are reasons RWA.NGO exists, and issuers can respond to either.
Third-party data platforms are never accepted as evidence.
How items become a score
Each grade earns a share of the item's credit, from full credit for independent verification down to none for the lowest tier. Items carry different importance, and dimensions carry different weights, depending on the product's legal structure. The single principle behind both is how much an investor could lose if that information were opaque or could not be verified. Weights are not published.
Items not yet assessed earn nothing, and the score is published anyway. The page shows how many items were verified, so the score reflects what is known today rather than what RWA.NGO plans to check.
Where an item is graded per chain or per share class, the results are weighted by the value on each chain or in each class at the scoring date. If RWA.NGO cannot read the supply on a chain, that chain's items are counted in the lowest tier and a risk note says how many chains are affected, so that a small chain is not hidden in the average.
Some evidence goes out of date: audited statements, reserve or holdings reports, and the stated size. When the next report is overdue, the item is counted one grade lower.
The total is out of 100 and falls in one of five tiers: Highly transparent and verified; Largely transparent; Partly transparent; Low transparency; Severely lacking. Each dimension is shown as a level rather than as points.
Risk notes
Risks that come from a product's structure, such as who can freeze or move tokens, how redemptions can be limited, or whether holders rank behind other creditors, are written out in full as risk notes, graded high, medium or low and sorted in that order. They do not change the score. Every inconsistency also has a risk note.
Inconsistencies
The page shows how many inconsistencies were found. The detail of each inconsistency and the evidence checked will be available to authorised members.
Corrections and issuer responses
Issuers and anyone else may add disclosures or dispute a finding by writing to contact@rwa.ngo, naming the product, the item and the supporting source. Each submission is checked and independently reviewed; until then the existing grade stands and the page notes that material has been received. Responses are listed in the issuer response record next to the score.
Findings from a disclosure case are reflected in the relevant items. The same issue is never deducted twice.
How the score is maintained
Every grade is set from archived documents and independently reviewed. The score is recalculated whenever a grade changes. Timeliness is currently checked manually; automated daily checks are in preparation. All products are reviewed monthly. The rules are reviewed every six months. Every scoring is kept as a dated record.
Questions and answers
Why are "not disclosed" and "inconsistent" in the same tier? In both cases an investor cannot rely on the information. The page invites the issuer to disclose or to explain.
Why does the issuer's own document not earn full credit? Investors most need evidence that does not depend on the issuer's own word. An issuer document approved by a regulator or a similar authority counts as independent.
Why do audited statements have a time limit that depends on the product? Statutory and customary publication periods differ by domicile and type of product, so the limit follows the period that applies rather than a single date for everyone.
Why are structural risks not part of the score? The score measures whether information is transparent and verifiable. A product can be fully transparent about a serious risk, so risks are stated in full and kept separate.
Why are the weights not equal, and why are they not published? Information that could cost investors more if it were wrong or missing counts for more. The weights are not published so that the score measures disclosure rather than an optimisation against a formula.
Why are chains weighted by value, with a separate note for chains that fail? Most of a product's value usually sits on a few chains. Weighting by value reflects that, and the separate note makes sure a problem on a smaller chain is still visible.
How can an issuer respond, and how long does it take? Write to contact@rwa.ngo with the product, the item and the supporting source. Each submission is checked and independently reviewed before a grade changes.
Limitations
Scores reflect the documents available on the scoring date. A high score does not mean the product is safe or suitable, and a low score does not mean that anything is wrong, only that less could be verified.
Cite this page
RWA Tokens Watch. (2026-10-20). Transparency & Verification Score (M-01, v1.2). https://rwa.ngo/en/methodology/structure-score