Inconsistencies, unverifiable figures and unclear structures, found while compiling product data. Each material issue is examined in its own case note, and issuers are invited to reply.
No case note has been published yet. Published case notes and issuer replies will be listed here.
Due diligence works better in the open
Every case note can be checked, answered and challenged. Investors, issuers, technical reviewers, journalists and researchers each have a way in. What you contribute is published under your name or a pseudonym, and results that contradict us are published too.
How a case unfolds
Day 0
Pre-notice
Facts, sources and questions go to the issuer before anything is public.
Issuer can correct facts
+5 business days
Published
The case note goes live with any comments received so far.
Everyone can read, check and cite
+15 business days
Reply window ends
Replies are published in full. No reply is recorded as such.
Issuer replies; reviewers check
+30 business days
Long overdue
The case stays open and the record shows the wait.
Late replies are always added
Any time
Outcome
Explained, corrected, disputed or unresolved. New evidence can reopen a case.
Give the source for every statement. Hearsay is not accepted.
Facts, not accusations
Describe what the documents and the chain show. Do not speculate about motive.
No private data, no intrusion
Do not access non-public systems or approach issuer staff under a false identity.
Declare your interests
Say whether you hold the product or work for the issuer or a competitor.
We check the form, not the verdict
Checks and tips are reviewed against these rules. Comments appear at once and are handled after posting: reported or rule-breaking comments are removed with a note.
Contributors
Empty until the first contribution is published.
Our boundaries
No payment from issuers for reviews. No bounties for now. No "scam" labels: descriptive verification statuses and factual event markers instead. No credit opinions or ESG scores at this stage. No product is named in a case note before its issuer has been notified.
Online forms open with the first published case. Until then, write to us.