How we review, how issuers reply, how we correct ourselves
Right of reply
Before we publish a case note that names a product, we send the issuer the facts, the sources and our numbered questions, with the planned publication date. This pre-notice period lasts 5 business days. It is a chance to correct facts. It is not a request for consent: if the issuer does not answer, the case note is published as planned.
- If the issuer shows that a fact is wrong, we correct it before publication and say so in the revision history.
- The issuer may ask once, during the pre-notice period, for publication to be postponed by up to 5 business days, if it commits to a substantive reply. The 10-business-day reply window after publication is unchanged. Extensions are recorded on the case page.
- After publication the issuer has a further 10 business days to reply. The countdown is shown on the case page.
- Replies are published in full and unedited up to 800 words. Longer material is linked. If an issuer asks us to keep something confidential, we publish only a summary it has agreed.
- When the reply window closes without a reply, the case is marked Reply overdue. Thirty business days after the first notice it is marked Long overdue. Late replies are always added, with the date received.
- Urgent track. Where holders may be affected now (redemptions blocked, backing in question, unusual minting, or a stale price feed still in use), the pre-notice period may be shortened to one full business day.
Data platforms, custodians, transfer agents and oracle providers named in a case note have the same right of reply. They are listed under "Also notified".
Business days are counted in the issuer's main jurisdiction.
Statuses and vocabulary
Every case uses one fixed vocabulary, in all five languages. The tables on this page list each status and who sets it. Confirmed findings are reflected in the relevant items of the Transparency & Verification Score, without a separate deduction.
- Level reflects the consequence for holders. Material: whether holders can redeem, whether the assets exist or are sufficient, core legal or eligibility terms, or a size difference of 10% or more. Notable: fees, returns, other terms, or a size difference of 5–10%. Minor: dates, names and labels.
- Evidence reflects how well a point is supported. Documented: primary documents or on-chain data that anyone can reproduce. Supported: mainly primary sources. Indicative: secondary sources only. Indicative issues are checked further and are not published as case notes.
- Cause: timing, definition, source error, our error, or unexplained.
Scores and rankings
The current Transparency & Verification Score is described in methodology M-01. It measures the transparency and verifiability of public product information, not credit quality, returns or suitability.
Confirmed findings are reflected in the relevant TVS items. There is no additional case-based deduction or grade ceiling. A case status alone does not change a score: changes follow the verification and review process.
Separate disclosure grades and rankings under methodology M-07 remain unimplemented. Their draft rules are not current TVS rules.
How we write
- Every figure shows its verification status. Verified figures show the type and date of the document they rest on; figures marked "Source not yet confirmed" are earlier research still to be checked against an archived original.
- Inference is labelled as inference, with the reasons for it.
- We describe what documents and the chain show. We do not speculate about motive.
- We do not use words such as "fraud", "scam", "glaring" or "catastrophic".
Sources
- Issuer documents and regulatory filings come first, then on-chain data at a stated block.
- Where a difference is visible only on a third-party data platform, we describe it and do not republish that platform's data.
- Documents behind verified figures are archived (original file, rendered page, retrieval time and checksum). Earlier research is archived as it is re-checked.
Corrections
We correct our own errors in public. Every correction to product data is recorded in the revision history of the product page, and every correction to a case note in our corrections log, including errors pointed out by issuers and readers. Where a case note turns out to be wrong, it is withdrawn: the text stays, with a withdrawal notice at the top explaining why.
To report an error, write to contact@rwa.ngo.
Comments
Comments are not open yet. The following rules describe the planned service, subject to a separate launch review. Once enabled, comments will appear at once and be handled after posting. Reader comments will not be verified by us.
- Facts with sources help most. Opinions are welcome; mark them as opinion.
- No personal data about others.
- No scams or phishing. Wallet-approval links, shortened links and known phishing domains are blocked automatically.
- No impersonation. Only verified accounts carry the "Verified issuer" mark. Issuers are welcome to answer comments directly.
- No pumping or market manipulation.
- No illegal content, spam or advertising.
- Report anything that breaks these rules. We act within 48 hours. Removed comments leave a note citing the rule.
Useful comments may be marked as leads by the editors and checked like any other tip.
Use of our assessments
Issuers and others may cite published TVS scores, verification statuses and case statuses on these terms. Separate disclosure grades, ranks and badges under M-07 are not available:
- Cite them with their date and methodology version, and link to the page on RWA.NGO.
- Link to the product page rather than copying a status, so readers see the current one.
- Do not change the wording, and do not present them as a certification, an endorsement or investment advice.
- Use them only for the product that was assessed.
- We will ask for outdated or misleading uses to be removed and will record them in our corrections log.
- Use is free of charge and needs no licence. Issuers remain responsible for their own financial promotions.
We do not issue product badges unasked.
Who produces our assessments
Assessments on RWA.NGO are produced by the operator named in our terms of use, under the methodology version shown on each page. We receive no payment from issuers for reviews.
Verification runs in two separate steps: one checks a value against the archived original, and a separate review confirms it without seeing the first check. The rules are in our verification principles and the status definitions in the glossary.